This Sounds Abysmal: At best. The Supremes, Sandy Day presiding, give lukewarm support to a "narrowly tailored" preference program at UMich. Upside: The points system used for the undergrads was found wanting. Downside: The reaffirming of the idea that, as this article puts it, "student body diversity is a compelling state interest that can justify use of race in admissions decisions." Down the road of that reasoning lies all sorts of evil.